Every winter, the median sale price in Summertown's 38483 ZIP code drops by tens of thousands of dollars. Over the same months, the price buyers pay per square foot hardly changes. Most of the winter dip comes from which houses sell, not from cheaper houses. This fall is different, though. Price per square foot has come down along with the median, and a buyer comparing Summertown with nearby towns should follow that number this season.
Unless another source is named, the market figures below come from Home Market View's page for ZIP 38483 and its pages for nearby towns. Each of those figures covers a rolling three-month window, so "December 2025" means the three months ending that December.
Two Summers, Two Winters, One Price per Foot
In the three months ending July 2025, the median Summertown sale was $395,000 and homes sold for $233.70 per square foot. In the three months ending December 2025, the median had fallen to $300,000, while price per square foot was $221.94. The median dropped by nearly a quarter. Price per square foot fell about 5%.
The winter before followed the same pattern. In the three months ending November 2024, the median was $350,000 at $227.13 a square foot. In the windows ending December 2024 and January 2025, the median was $320,000 and price per square foot held at $215.63.
The likely explanation is the mix of homes that change hands. Summertown is a small market. Only 24 homes sold in the three months ending October 2026. In a sample that small, a few larger homes or acreage properties closing in summer push the median up, and a winter dominated by smaller houses pulls it down. Price per square foot adjusts for size, so it moves much less. From late 2024 through 2026, price per square foot stayed between about $211 and $234 while the median ranged from $300,000 to $395,000.
So when a Summertown median looks low in January, it doesn't by itself mean homes got cheaper. It mainly tells you smaller homes made up more of the sales.
This Fall, Both Numbers Came Down Together
In the three months ending October 2026, the 38483 median was $324,833. That is 6.7% below the same window in 2025. Price per square foot for that window was $212.63, down from $227.14 in the three months ending October 2025. That's roughly a 6% decline in the measure that usually holds steady from one year to the next.
The drop started before the usual winter season. Summertown homes sold for $228.37 a square foot in the window ending August 2026, then $213.01 in the window ending September. The September figure was lower than any three-month window from May 2025 through August 2026.
Homes are also staying on the market longer. The median Summertown home took 83 days to sell in the three months ending October 2026. Across all of Lawrence County, the median was 70 days, with 5.3 months of supply and 212 homes for sale, according to a LocalAlpha market brief published October 29, 2026. A typical Summertown home is taking about two weeks longer to sell than the county median, and the county has more than five months' worth of homes for sale.
No other window from November 2025 on fell as far below its year-earlier price per square foot as October 2026 did. Because price per square foot accounts for house size, that decline is the change a buyer would see in an offer price.
Winter Leaves You Fewer Homes to Choose From
There is one tradeoff. Summertown has fewer listings in winter, and that pattern repeats every year.
There were 69 active listings during the three months ending October 2026, counting every home on the market at any point in that window. That is 5.5% fewer than a year earlier. Last winter, the count fell to 52 in the windows ending January and February 2026. The winter before, it bottomed at 48 in the window ending January 2025. Summer and fall windows usually run around 69 to 73.
A buyer looking from Thanksgiving through February will probably see about a quarter fewer Summertown homes than in summer, at a lower price per square foot than last year. The market is softer than it was, but there are fewer homes to pick from.
How Summertown Compares With Lawrenceburg and Columbia
Price per square foot is also a fairer way to compare Summertown with nearby towns, because their homes differ in size.
In the three months ending October 2026, Lawrenceburg's median sale was $264,816 at $174.74 a square foot. Homes there sold in a median 65 days, and the median was up 11.5% from a year earlier. Columbia, about 32 minutes up the road according to Travelmath, had a median of $354,753 at $199.73 a square foot over the same window, with a median of 75 days on market and a 1.4% decline from the year before.
| Three months ending October 2026 | Median sale price | Price per sq ft | Median days on market | Year-over-year median change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Summertown, ZIP 38483 | $324,833 | $212.63 | 83 | -6.7% |
| Lawrenceburg | $264,816 | $174.74 | 65 | +11.5% |
| Columbia | $354,753 | $199.73 | 75 | -1.4% |
Summertown's median is below Columbia's, yet Summertown homes sold for more per square foot than either Columbia or Lawrenceburg. Even after this fall's decline, a square foot of house costs more in 38483 than in either neighboring town. Summertown's median is lower mostly because the homes that sold there were smaller, not because the price per square foot was lower.
Of the three towns, Lawrenceburg's price was rising fastest this fall and its homes sold quickest. Summertown had the highest price per square foot, the slowest sales and the largest year-over-year decline. A buyer choosing between them this winter is weighing a higher, falling price per square foot in Summertown against a lower, rising one in Lawrenceburg. For more on the area, see the Summertown neighborhood page and the Lawrenceburg neighborhood page.
Water Service in Summertown Over the Next Year
Summertown's water supply will also change over the next year, and it is worth checking for any home you're considering.
Summertown Utility District serves 2,046 meters, 1,924 of them active, and delivers more than 8 million gallons of water a year, according to the Lawrence County Advocate. In an August 2025 post titled "WATER IS LIFE," the Lawrence County executive's office said the district has a well but regularly buys more water from Lawrenceburg Utilities System. LUS can produce 9 million gallons a day against average demand of about 3 million.
In July 2026, the district announced $5.5 million in USDA funding, a $679,000 grant and a $4,821,000 40-year loan. The money pays for bringing the Caldwell Road well into service, piping its water to the district's plant, building a filtration plant and replacing older mains "in areas that have been troublesome for the past several years," the district told the Lawrence County Advocate. The Caldwell Road well was dug about 20 years ago but couldn't be used at the time because of groundwater seepage. On the district's schedule, design wraps up by December, bids go out by February 2027, construction starts in the spring and the project finishes by fall 2027.
New lots are being added to the system too. On February 17, 2026, the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation approved construction of the district's 2025 Buffalo Estates Water Line Extension, about 1,484 feet of 6-inch line serving 13 residential lots.
For a buyer, the first question on any Summertown listing is whether the house is on district water or a private well. If it's on district water, ask the seller how service has been on that street, since the district's own description of its main replacements mentions problem areas. If you're looking at land, our earlier post on buying land in Summertown covers other questions to ask before you sign.
If you're weighing a Summertown home this winter, I can walk you through how its asking price per square foot compares with what Summertown homes sold for last fall and this year. With Heidi Osterheld, you'll know whether the asking price reflects this fall's softer market or last summer's prices before you write an offer. Let's Connect.